The Best Vibrating Dog Collars For Gentle Pet Training - Dogtime (2023)

Not ready for shocks? These vibrating dog collars produce similar training results without the use of physical pain.

Dog training can be a difficult task. Some pups do well with bite-sized treats, while others require more intervention. Vibrating dog collars are an excellent tool for effective, pain-free training. They put out a mixture of beeps and vibrations when your pet does something wrong. They’re typically controlled via remote, leaving you with all of the training power. And along with producing quick results, they’re fairly easy on the wallet. Read on to discover some of our favorite vibrating dog collars from Amazon today.

Best Vibrating Dog Collars to Consider

Before you purchase a vibrating dog collar, there are a few questions that you will want to consider. First, try to think about all of the efforts that are going into training your pup. It’s important to not only use a vibrating dog collar, but also a combination of other practices. This should include positive rewards, such as treats or bones. If you’re looking for a quality dog treat, these blueberry-based treats are great options.

Next, make sure the collar you choose fits your lifestyle. You will want to look into the range, for example, to make sure it’s long enough to work from anywhere on your property. Ranges vary from about 1600 feet to 3300 feet. Consider the method of correction you prefer, between pressing the button yourself and collars that do the work for you when triggered (typically used for barking correction). Make sure the collar is waterproof if you play outside in all types of weather. And also check the battery life — some vibrating dog collars need to be charged every few days while others last up to 20.

Last but not least, consider your pet’s personality and the behaviors they are currently struggling with. If only small changes need to be made, any collar should do the trick. But if your pet is more stubborn than most or requires serious correction, you may need a product with several vibration levels. You can start at the lowest one and work your way up until the behavior has come to an end.

Paipaitek vibrating dog collar

This vibrating dog collar makes pet training simple. It comes with a remote and a keychain clicker, so you can address concerning behaviors from anywhere. The signal range is 3300 feet, so it’s no big deal if your pup is across the yard from you when something goes wrong. The levels go from 1 to 100, giving you tons of wiggle room to adjust to your pet’s needs. The collar itself is waterproof for rainy days or swimming adventures, too.


  • Average price point
  • Prong-free
  • Long-lasting battery works for up to 20 days
  • Ideal for pets that weigh 4-120 pounds
  • Same remote can be used for up to 3 collars for multi-pet homes


  • Makes a beeping sound when powered on, which some dogs don’t appreciate

PetJoy vibrating dog collar

The Best Vibrating Dog Collars For Gentle Pet Training - Dogtime (2)

Runner Up

Find on Amazon

(Video) Best Dog Training Collar 2022-2023 🏆 Top 5 Best Dog Training Collars Reviews

This training collar provides a combination of vibrations and beeps to gently remind your pet to do the right thing. It has ten strength levels for each of the following modes: beep, vibration, and beep/vibration combined. The collar is weatherproof for outdoor play and works from distances up to 1500 feet away from the receiver. Both the remote and the collar are rechargeable, with the collar lasting around 20 days and the remote lasting up to 180.


  • Low price
  • USB charging cable included
  • Can be used on dogs 4-150 pounds
  • Submersible for swimming and baths


  • Best suited for small and medium-sized breeds

Brapezie vibrating dog collar

This unique dog collar has built-in LED lights, making it easier to spot your pup outside at night. The light can also be used as an extremely gentle training method. Other training modes include beeps and vibrations. Each type has 16 levels, so you can start with the lowest and work your way up as needed. The collar works from up to 2000 feet away. The battery lasts for about 15 days, while the receiver battery lasts closer to 45. The slim remote is comfortable to hold and the LED screen makes setting selection a breeze.


  • Reasonable price
  • Fits dogs 20-110 pounds
  • “Lost mode” makes the light blink if your pet wanders off at night
  • Built-in lock on remote prevents accidental punishments


(Video) Which Dog Training Collar Is Right For YOUR Dog?

  • Charging port must be closed for the collar to be waterproof

Paipaitek vibrating dog collars, 2 pack

If you are training more than one dog, this two-pack of vibrating collars could make life simpler. Both collars can be controlled by the same remote — just choose “dog 1” or “dog 2” before sending signals. The correction methods include beep, vibration, and beep/vibration combined. The remote works from 1600 feet away, so you don’t have to stay right next to two dogs at the same time. And the collars are completely waterproof for rainy days, swimming, or bath time.


  • Affordable
  • Lightweight remote control
  • 20-day battery life
  • Recharge via USB


  • Vibrations may be slightly gentler than other collars

StopWoofer vibrating dog collar

The Best Vibrating Dog Collars For Gentle Pet Training - Dogtime (5)

StopWoofer no pain barking vibrating dog collar

(Video) Want to find the best prong collar to get for your dog and how to get the perfect walk? #shorts

Best For Barking

Find on Amazon

This vibrating collar strives to prevent nuisance barking. Instead of having to press a button on a remote every time you need to correct the behavior, it vibrates and beeps at the sound of your pet’s voice. It can be put on your dog during the times when he is not supposed to bark and taken off when he may need to make noise to protect you. There are 7 levels of correction, which cycle through automatically depending on how well your pet is listening. And if they keep barking even when their collar is on, the device will turn off after 1 minute to prevent extensive punishment. It’s easy to charge the collar via USB and it lasts for around 14 days between power-ups.


  • Fair price
  • Typically produces results within two weeks
  • Highly adjustable strap
  • No training effort is required on your part


  • Only for correcting excessive barking

Frequently Asked Questions

Are vibrating dog collars humane?

Yes. Vibrating dog collars do not cause pain. They deliver a vibration that dogs do not enjoy, but it does not hurt them. This vibration can be used on very low levels, almost like a reminder to dogs that their behavior wasn’t desirable. Vibrating collars can be paired with praise training as well — give your pup a training treat when they do as the collar asked. You may even want to reward them with something larger, like a bully stick, when they make a significant positive change.

Do vibrating dog collars work as well as shock collars?

For many dogs, vibrating dog collars can work just as well or even better than shock collars. They typically do not cause the fear and anxiety that can come with pain-based training. They do require consistency to be effective, but that is true of all forms of dog training.

Do I need to use a vibrating dog collar forever?

No. Vibrating dog collars can be used during the training process and removed once your pet understands the appropriate action.

If I have multiple pets, do they each need their own vibrating dog collar?

Yes, if you are training both pets at the same time. You may want to purchase a two-dog pack to save some money and simplify the dog training tools you have at home.

What types of behaviors can vibrating dog collars correct?

These products are often used to help dogs stop barking, though dog barking collars exist for this purpose as well. Vibrating collars can also be used to prevent other nuisance behaviors, such as stealing food, jumping on people, tables, or counters, pulling on a leash, chasing other pets, and more.

About the Author

Jessica is the proud owner of two dogs: an adorable dalmatian and a very active retriever mix. With all her years of experience caring for her own pups, Jessica hopes to help other dog moms and dads make the most of their time with their furry friends by finding them products that make dog ownership convenient, easy, and fun. As a mom of two, Jessica is always looking for products that are safe for her dog, her kids, and her home.

(Video) Best Bark Collar For Dogs in 2022 - TOP 10 Review

Why Trust Us

Since 2008, DogTime has served as a leading resource for millions of dog owners and pet lovers alike. Our goal is to give every dog and pet a happy, healthy home by providing owners with all the information they need to be the best pet parents possible. Our experts share their insights and recommendations to make caring for your beloved pets a breeze.


What is the best humane vibration collar? ›

The #1 Best Overall vibrating dog collar is the Goodboy Remote Collar. Vibrating dog collars are a painless way to train your dog when it comes to unwarranted barking and other behavior. They are a great alternative to shock collars.

Do dog trainers recommend vibrating collars? ›

Many dog trainers suggest vibration collars as an alternative to shock collars since they work by sensation but don't induce pain.

What is the most humane dog training collar? ›

Quick List of the Top No Shock Dog Training Collars
  • WOLFWILL Waterproof Rechargeable Remote-Operated Dog Training Collar (Best Overall)
  • Paipaitek No Prongs Humane Vibration Dog Collar (Best Vibration Collar)
  • DogRook Adjustable Anti-Barking Collar for Dogs (Best Anti-Barking Collar)

What collar does Cesar recommend? ›

The Halo Collar and Wireless Dog Fence is a precise tool that will communicate with your dog at exactly the right time, allowing them to seamlessly form the associations they need to keep them safely within their designated boundaries.

What is the difference between electric and vibration collar? ›

A vibration collar uses varying levels of vibration whereas a shock collar uses static correction. Although it is a misconception that shock collars give your dog an actual “shock“, vibration collars are considered to be milder in sensation.

What is the difference between shock and vibration on an e collar? ›

Shock collars are also known as dog training collars, e-collars, or electronic collars. These training devices work by first giving your dog a warning beep or vibration, which is followed by a remote shock if he doesn't stop the bad behavior.

Why doesn't my dog respond to vibration collar? ›

Make sure your battery is charged in both the collar and the transmitter. Low battery charge can make for inconsistent functioning. Make sure both pieces are turned on and that the unit is properly synced so that the collar is receiving a signal from the transmitter.

Why doesn't my dog respond to vibrate collar? ›

There could be several reasons why the dog doesn't respond to shock collar. First, ensure the collar is functioning correctly and has the proper intensity. If the collar is too loose or not charged, it may be ineffective, causing the dog not responding to shock collar.

What collars do vets recommend? ›

All dogs need a collar, and the Dogs Trust recommend the "use of flat, fixed collars, which do not tighten or constrict around your dog's neck."

Does Cesar Millan use training collars? ›

The answer is yes, Cesar Millan does occasionally use an E collar for training purposes. However, he doesn't do so frequently and only uses it when absolutely necessary.

What dog collars do police dogs use? ›

The basic collar that each dog in the K9 program wears is a chain choke collar. The handlers mostly use the stationary ring of the collar when leading the dog, and sometimes the active ring when corrections might be needed.

What is good training collar for a dog? ›

Patpet Dog Shock Collar – Best Overall

The Patpet Dog Shock Collar has a wide range of 1000 feet, so you can easily control the collar from inside your house when your dog is out in the yard. It comes with three training modes, which include a static shock, vibration and beep modes.

What age can you use a vibration collar? ›

In conclusion, expert opinions generally agree that you should wait until a dog is at least 6 months old before using a shock collar.

How tight should a vibration collar be? ›

For vibration-activated spray collars: The collar needs to be fitted high up on your dog's neck and adjusted tight enough so that it doesn't move side to side. This ensures the collar consistently picks up the vibration of your dog's vocal cords and delivers the spray stimulation consistently.

Do bark collars shock or vibrate? ›

Electronic bark collars detect the vibration of the vocal cords as your dog barks. When it detects these vibrations, a low-level shock is delivered to the dog's neck.

Do vets recommend shock collars? ›

The experts advise against using shock collars. Veterinary associations and humane organizations have long recognized that punishment-based training can be detrimental to animals.

Are vibrating dog collars mean? ›

If you want to ensure that your dog is treated humanely, a vibration collar is a much gentler alternative to shock collars. Instead of using pain and fear to discourage bad behavior, vibrating dog collars redirect your dogs attention and encourage them to make the right choices.

Which is better e-collar or prong collar? ›

One major benefit of the remote training collar over the prong collar and many other tools is that we are not required to have a leash attached to the device in order for us to benefit from it. As such, the e-collar gives us the ability to effectively communicate with the dog, off-leash and at great distances.

Do vibration collars cause anxiety in dogs? ›

Punishment-based dog training methods usually involve training collars like shock collars (otherwise known as e-collars), bark collars, and prong collars. While these methods may give short-term results, they can create behavioral issues, such as fear reactions, insecurity, and overall stress.

Are dogs sensitive to vibrations? ›

There are some sounds dogs can hear and we can't- not due to volume, but due to pitch. Humans can hear sounds that vibrate at a pitch of 20 000 vibrations per second or less, depending on age. Dogs, however, can hear sounds that vibrate up to 50 000 vibrations per second.

How do you train a dog to recall with a vibration collar? ›

How to Teach Your Dog Recall Using E-Collar
  1. Find the Right Collar Settings. ...
  2. Practice Commands Without E-Collar. ...
  3. Introduce Commands Applying E-Collar Pressure. ...
  4. Repeat, Repeat, Repeat!
May 10, 2022

How do you stop bad behavior with a vibration collar? ›

How to Properly Train a Dog with a Shock Collar
  1. Purchase a Quality Product. ...
  2. Start with the Basics. ...
  3. Show Your Dog the Behavior You Want. ...
  4. Combine the Collar with Positive Reinforcement. ...
  5. Use 'vibrate Mode' on the Collar. ...
  6. Know When to Ask for Help. ...
  7. Know When to Quit.
Sep 12, 2022

How do I train my dog not to bark with a vibrating collar? ›

The collar should be snug but not too tight. Follow the manufacturer's guidelines for proper fitting. Before using the vibration collar to stop barking, it's essential to introduce the dog to the collar gradually. Allow the dog to wear the collar without activating it for a few days to get used to its presence.

How do I stop barking with a vibrating collar? ›

Vibration Collars

These operate both by hearing a bark and by sensing the vibration in the dog's throat. Therefore, only the dog wearing the device will trigger the vibration response. The vibration is designed to distract your dog and therefore stop the barking.

What does vibration do to a dog? ›

“I have nerve damage and vibrations actually work to open up the nerve channels and alleviate pain. That relieves inflammation, too,” he said. Henson said customers can step onto the platform with their dogs if they need to quell canine nerves.

Why does my dog hate it when I make a buzzing sound? ›

Dogs do have much more sensitive hearing than humans and this may be partially to blame for their noise reactivity. A sound that is loud to us is experienced at a much higher volume by our dogs. Dogs can also hear sounds at higher frequencies or pitches than humans.

Why isn't my dog answering me? ›

The reasons your dog may not be listening might be medical in nature, but most often, if your dog will not come to you or ignores you completely, it is because of a training or a behavioral issue. Once you feel you have ruled out potential illness, training and conditioning your dog will improve his recall ability.

What colors are calming to dogs? ›

Blue and violet are also more emotionally calming and can help to reduce stress levels. These colors are preferable in the veterinary setting because they appear in lighter tones to animals and do not seem as abrasive as white or as dull as gray.

What is a calming collar for dogs? ›

CALMING COLLAR FOR DOGS: SENTRY Calming Collars contain a pheromone that is scientifically proven to reduce fear of loud noises, bad behavior and barking. HAPPIER LESS STRESSFUL LIVES: Dog calming collar helps to reduce your dog's stress-related behavior.

What to look for when buying a dog training collar? ›

Best features of dog training collars:
  • A design made specifically for your dog training goals (yard training, bark training or training a hunting dog or working dog)
  • A large enough (or small enough) size to fit your dog.
  • Humane stimulation, such as a tone, vibration or E-Collar's patented blunt pulse stimulation.

What is the difference between a dog trainer and a dog whisperer? ›

Thus, a dog whisperer will try to understand why a dog tends to bark incessantly. A dog trainer, on the other hand, will train a dog to stop this annoying behavior. That's the key difference!

Does Halo collar have a monthly fee? ›

Halo Care allows you to buy a replacement collar for $149 for any reason with a monthly subscription of $9.99 per collar. Once you have purchased a Halo Collar and after you have signed up for a Halo Subscription Plan, that collar will be eligible to be enrolled in Halo Care within 60 days of activation.

Can a dog wear a training collar all the time? ›

As far as the safety factors involved in wear time, understand that a dog CANNOT wear the e-collar 24/7. Wearing the collar constantly will cause skin irritation and potential pressure sores due to the snug fit required for proper use.

What collar do military dogs wear? ›

Nylon Agitation Collar With Cobra Buckle & Handle - Made with Mil-Spec nylon, this collar is rigid & durable. It includes a soft loop to eliminate rattle from metal on metal and terminates into a Mil-Spec cobra buckle for added security.

Why do cops hold their collars? ›

The vest hang: A natural transition from the pit tuck, the vest hang is clasping the top of the vest near their collarbones to keep arms from hitting the equipment on the duty belt. The crossed arms: This can look intimidating, but cops use this stance solely for comfort.

What dogs do police use the most? ›

They are the Belgian Malinois and the German Shepherd. The most popular breed of police dog is the well-known German Shepherd, a 200 year old breed in the herding class of working dogs.

What are the names of the 3 types of collars? ›

There are several types of collars. The three basic types are flat, standing, and rolled.

Is it better to train a dog with a collar or harness? ›

In general, it's better to start your puppy's leash training with a harness and move on to a collar later. This is because puppies tend to pull strongly when first learning to walk on a leash. A collar might push on your puppy's trachea when they pull, possibly damaging it.

Should collar be tight or loose? ›

As tight or snug as possible without being uncomfortable. You should be able to fit 1-2 fingers between the collar and your neck when it is buttoned. You should not have a large gap showing between the collar and neck. Heavier men should make sure their necks are not puffing out over the top of the collar.

Do vibrating dog collars work? ›

Vibrating collars can be effective in stopping unwanted behaviors, but they may not be the best choice for all dogs or all behaviors. For example, if your dog has a severe fear or anxiety issue, a vibrating collar may not be the best solution.

What is the difference between a shock collar and a vibration collar? ›

Vibration Collar vs Shock Collar

A vibration collar uses varying levels of vibration whereas a shock collar uses static correction. Although it is a misconception that shock collars give your dog an actual “shock“, vibration collars are considered to be milder in sensation.

Why did Petco stop selling shock collars? ›

Ron Coughlin, CEO of Petco, said selling shock collars doesn't align with the company's mission of improving the lives of both pets and people. “Electricity is fine for your microwave, but not fine for your pets, so we shouldn't sell these things,” he told TODAY.

What can I use instead of a shock collar? ›

Alternatives to Shock Collars
  • Clicker Training. Clickers are a great tool to use with behavioral training. ...
  • Citronella Collars. Yes, citronella is typically used to ward off mosquitoes. ...
  • Whistles. ...
  • Pheromones and Scents.
Feb 28, 2018

Are vibration dog collars humane? ›

If you want to ensure that your dog is treated humanely, a vibration collar is a much gentler alternative to shock collars. Instead of using pain and fear to discourage bad behavior, vibrating dog collars redirect your dogs attention and encourage them to make the right choices.

What is the best alternative to an e collar for cats? ›

Seven alternatives to the cone of shame
  1. The BiteNot Collar. This device does not represent the shape of a cat or dog cone at all; it most resembles a neck brace. ...
  2. The ProCollar Premium Protective Collar. ...
  3. Kong EZ Soft Collar. ...
  4. Comfy Collar. ...
  5. The Boobooloon. ...
  6. Optivisor or Novaguard. ...
  7. TCOA Soft E-Fabric Collar.

Is there an alternative to the E collar? ›

Any dog cone alternative including inflatable collars, flexible and soft fabric e-collars, and clothing like onesies and bodysuits can be used instead of a traditional e-collar. Make sure whatever you decide to use protects the affected area from your dog's biting or licking.

Does Cesar Millan use electric collars? ›

Yes, Cesar Millan is a known proponent of using the e collar in certain training situations. The e collar, or “electronic” collar, is one of the most useful and effective tools for teaching your dog positive behaviors – and getting rid of unwanted ones.

What are the side effects of vibration collars? ›

Shock collars can harm your dog. The electrostatic shock can cause psychological distress for your pet, including phobias and high levels of stress, and can result in unhealthy increases in heart rate and painful burns to your dog's skin.

Do vets recommend e-collars? ›

This method of training also poses fewer risks to dog welfare and quality of the human-dog relationship. Given these results we suggest that there is no evidence to indicate that E-collar training is necessary, even for its most widely cited indication.

What is the cone of shame on a cat? ›

The dreaded cone of shame! Also commonly referred to as the "lampshade" or the "radar dish," but officially called the Elizabethan collar. Your veterinarian might give you this super stylish Elizabethan collar to protect your cat's recent surgery site from licking and chewing.

What is an e-collar for dog training? ›

An E-Collar is a remote dog training system that usually consists of a wireless remote and a wireless receiver. E-collars allow you to remotely send signals to your dog to help them understand "good behavior" and "bad behavior."

What is the cone of shame called? ›

Global survey of pet owners reveals the Elizabeth collar or Cone of Shame impacts negatively on their pets.

What are the negative side effects of an e-collar? ›

Shock collars can cause dogs physical pain, injury (ranging from burns to cardiac fibrillation), and psychological stress, including severe anxiety and displaced aggression. Individual animals vary in their temperaments and pain thresholds; a shock that seems mild to one dog might be severe to another.

Should you train with an e-collar? ›

With the ability to communicate and reinforce commands from a distance, e-collars can help you train your dog more effectively, leading to a well-behaved and obedient pet. A trained dog is a happy dog, as they clearly understand their role and the rules they are expected to follow.

Is there a training collar that doesn't shock? ›

no shock dog training collar is more suitable for deaf dogs, puppy, small, medium-sized dogs (4-60 pounds). UP TO 1600FT REMOTE RANGE & IPX7 WATERPROOF - No shock dog collar with remote up to 1600ft control range, easy to train your dog in the backyard, park and beach.

Does Cesar Millan use negative reinforcement? ›

Cesar Millan, the well-known television dog trainer, has said that some dogs may need to be negatively reinforced before they are ready and open to positive reinforcement. His belief has yet to be proved or disproved by published scientific research.


1. Bark Collars - How to train your dog using Bark Collars?
(The Dog Line)
2. Prong Collar
(Southend Dog Training)
3. Calming dogs with a pheromone collar
(VCA Ballston Spa Animal Hospital)
4. PetSafe® Training with an Electronic Remote Training System
(PetSafe International)
5. Regarding prong collars…
(American Standard Dog Training)
6. How to Use an Electric Collar to Train a Dog to Come When called
(Ty The Dog Guy)


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner

Last Updated: 04/30/2023

Views: 6462

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner

Birthday: 1994-06-25

Address: Suite 153 582 Lubowitz Walks, Port Alfredoborough, IN 72879-2838

Phone: +128413562823324

Job: IT Strategist

Hobby: Video gaming, Basketball, Web surfing, Book restoration, Jogging, Shooting, Fishing

Introduction: My name is Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner, I am a zany, graceful, talented, witty, determined, shiny, enchanting person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.