Teaching pets to walk appropriately on a leash is imperative. Occasional prong collar use can make the training process a breeze.
Prong collars are a helpful but often misunderstood training tool. They can help teach even the most stubborn pets to walk gently on a leash. When used appropriately, they are designed to put pressure on your pet, not produce pain. However, there is much to learn to get to this place when using one of your own. Below, we’ll dissect the best dog prong collars on the market today, as well as continue to learn about using these tools with our pups. By the end of this article, we hope you’ll not only be ready to train your pet with one — if it’s a good fit for them, of course — but also know exactly which version you’d like to buy.
Best Dog Prong Collars to Consider
As mentioned above, there is a lot to learn about prong collars before you’ll be ready to use one with your pet. To start, it’s important to understand that there is a widespread stigma around this product. In advertisements and media, these tools are often used to depict aggressive, uncontrollable dogs. They often represent owners who do not care about their pets as well. When in reality, this is the furthest from the truth.Prong collars are a communication tool for pets who learn best through touch instead of words. They are to be used as a command, not as a punishment.
Next, consider where your dog is at with leash walking. If they already know how to walk gently, a prong collar isn’t necessary. If they pull often and have been hard to correct with treats and verbal commands, a prong collar could be your quickest and most effective solution.
Now, think of your pet’s size. Prong collars are not for little dogs. They are for large and strong dogs only. It’s also imperative that they are sized correctly. Prong collars that are too small may hurt your pet, and they may fall off of your dog if they are too large.
Remember that prong collars are only meant to be used for short periods of time when you are walking your pet. Long, unsupervised wear sessions often lead to injuries.
Get to know a few features of prong collars, such as capped or uncapped prongs. Capped prongs are more comfortable for pets, while uncapped are slightly sharper. Neither will scratch skin if used appropriately. Look into quick-release buckles, too, which greatly ease the burden of putting prong collars on and taking them off.
And last but not least, remember that these are training tools that work for some dogs but not all. Use should be discontinued if the collar you purchase does not produce results after a few weeks. This helps to ensure you aren’t making your dog uncomfortable for no reason when other training methods could be more effective for their personality type.
Adjustable and safe prong dog collar
This prong collar has several unique features to help keep your pet comfortable and ease the training process. To start, all of the prongs are rounded to prevent injuries. They have rubber tips for added cushion, and they also come with extra rubber pieces in case a few fall off and get lost. The buckle makes the collar easy to put on and take off, and the D-rings provide a simple connection point and ensure even neck pressure. The collar has three built-in size settings, and you can adjust the fittings further by adding or removing links. The price is reasonable for such a thoughtful product as well.
- Small, medium, and large sizes are available
- Several colors to choose from
- The buckle can be removed with one hand in emergencies
- Steel material is resistant to rust
- Breed examples for each size are listed on the product page
- Needs to be dried quickly if it gets wet
Quick release prong dog collar
This prong dog collar has a quick-release button, which makes it much easier to put on and take off. It’s also helpful in emergencies, since it could be life-threatening to take 5 minutes to undo prongs in some circumstances. Sizes small through extra-large are available, and each size can be adjusted further by adding or removing links. Prongs are covered with removable rubber tips. The body of the collar is made of stainless steel, allowing for increased durability and rust-resistance compared to other similar products. You can even make your purchase a little more joyful by choosing one of the colorful patterns that Deyace has to offer.
- Average price
- Well-built design
- Weight suggestions for each size are listed on the product page
- Prongs require pliers for removable, which helps to ensure your pup won’t be able to break them off himself
- Rubber tips may fall off, but the prongs underneath are rounded and extra caps are included
Undetectable prong dog collar
This unique product helps you skip some of the judgment by hiding the prongs underneath what appears to be a regular nylon collar. It has a quick-release buckle and a sturdy D-ring for durability and pressure distribution. Extra prongs are included for size adjustment and they can also be removed to make the collar smaller. Sizes start in small through extra-large positions — just choose the version that will fit your pet or be slightly too big and adjust as needed. Several fun colors and patterns are available to click through when you make your purchase.
- Typical price point
- Rounded prongs with rubber tips
- Reinforced buckle
- Made of stainless steel
- Even though this looks like a normal collar, it can still only be used for short periods of time while your pet is on a leash
Sensitive skin dog prong collar
As great as prong collars are, they are often made with cheaper metals that dogs and humans can have skin allergies to. If your pet has shown signs of metal allergies in the past, this quality prong collar from Herm Spregner could be a good fit. It’s made entirely of Curogan metal, which has a high amount of copper in it. There is no nickel, which happens to be the most common metal allergy. The collar is professional-grade and has two o-rings for customizable leash placement. The prongs aren’t completely rounded, but they also aren’t sharp. The one-size-fits-all product can be adjusted to suit dogs with neck circumferences of 20” or smaller by adding or removing links as needed.
- Can be polished if the color darkens over time
- Also available in 16” or 25” sizes
- Releases quickly even without a buckle
- Higher than average price
- No rubber caps for prongs
Classic dog prong collar
Best On A Budget
Prong dog collars can be effective even if they aren’t fancy, and this product from Monlida serves as proof. It’s affordably priced, comfortable for pets, and easy to use for pet owners. The prongs are covered with rubber tips. Four sizes are available to choose from, as well as versions with and without buckles. The length can be adjusted further by adding or removing links. Two o-rings are included, so you can choose to use the slip style or traditional style depending on what works best for your pup.
- Low price point
- Customizable features
- Easy to detach
- Made of stainless steel
- Extra links are not included, but universal pieces work fine
Frequently Asked Questions
Are prong dog collars safe?
Prong collars are safe when used appropriately. They should only be used for short amounts of time and only while your dog is on a leash. They should be removed if your pet shows persistence in pulling even with the collar on. It’s safer to use versions with rubber tips than bare-metal types.
Are dog prong collars humane?
Prong dog collars are humane when, again, used appropriately. The dog may feel uncomfortable when they pull, but they will be able to alleviate the feeling by correcting their behavior. They should not be in pain. And the collar should be removed if they are not responding to the pressure.
Do dog prong collars produce results for all pets?
No. Some dogs perform well with physical reminders to training, while others do much better with positive reinforcement. They work well for strong-willed dogs of large breeds, They are not safe to use with small breeds.
How can I train my pet with a prong collar?
Prong collars can be used when training your dog to walk on a leash without pulling. It should be placed directly behind your dog’s ears and below their jaw line. Provide small but firm tugs to correct behavior as needed. Remove the dog collar when you are done with your walk.
Why do prong collars have a bad reputation?
All prong collars product an uncomfortable sensation to correct behaviors. Though this is effective, it is also controversial. Prong collars can also be dangerous when they are not used correctly, which adds to the stigma behind them. Last but not least, they are to be used as a training aid. They are not a means to walk a dog on a leash who has never been trained to avoid pulling.
About the Author
Jessica is the proud owner of two dogs: an adorable dalmatian and a very active retriever mix. With all her years of experience caring for her own pups, Jessica hopes to help other dog moms and dads make the most of their time with their furry friends by finding them products that make dog ownership convenient, easy, and fun. As a mom of two, Jessica is always looking for products that are safe for her dog, her kids, and her home.
Why Trust Us
Since 2008, DogTime has served as a leading resource for millions of dog owners and pet lovers alike. Our goal is to give every dog and pet a happy, healthy home by providing owners with all the information they need to be the best pet parents possible. Our experts share their insights and recommendations to make caring for your beloved pets a breeze.
Can prong collars be used on puppies? ›
Should I Use a Prong Collar on Puppies? If you have a 3- to 4-month-old puppy that is pulling you down the street while on a walk, then you need a prong collar. In this case, you won't need to 'pop' the collar to correct your puppy. The puppy will give itself a correction when he hits the end of the leash.What is the best collar for a puppy walking? ›
Martingale collars are the best option for new puppies starting to walk on a leash. These collars gradually tighten as they pull on them, which ensures your pup can't slip out.Are prong collars good for leash training? ›
Prong collars are painful and unethical training collars. Owners use this on their dogs in an attempt to stop them from pulling on the lead. They can cause serious harm to dogs and are an ineffective training method.Can you use prong collars for walks? ›
If you have a dog you can't control on the leash or need help right away, then the prong collar is the tool for you. It's the best training collar option for using the gentle “pressure and release” technique to gain control on the walk. Plus, when positioned correctly, it distributes the pressure around the dog's neck.What is the difference between a prong collar and a pinch collar? ›
Pinch Collar vs Prong Collar
While some may think pinch and prong collars are different, they refer to the same type of collar. The term pinch refers to the way you have to pinch the prongs to open and close the collar, while prong relates to the prongs that protrude toward the neck and are the mechanism for training.
Walking on a leash is an essential skill which can be learned by puppies as early as eight weeks old. Some master leash training quickly, while others take a little longer. Either way, it's important to remain consistent, positive – and above all, patient.Is it better to walk a puppy on a leash or harness? ›
Which is Safest: Harness or Collar? While a flat collar is best for everyday wear and for displaying ID tags, our experts agree that a harness is the safest option for going on walks and other outdoor activities or situations that might cause your puppy to pull on the leash.What are the negatives of a prong collar? ›
Prong collars can result in side effects such as depression, disempowerment, redirected aggression, deterioration of social relationships, and more. Use pain and fear-inducing methods on your dog for long enough, and you can see a significant decrease in your dog's quality of life, energy, and health.What is better than a prong collar? ›
For shorter walks, a Gentle Leader might be fine. For longer walks, the pinch collar might be better. And just for the record, the Halti Head Collar is a similar tool to the Gentle Leader, but it's designed better and typically doesn't put too much pressure on a dog's nose or eyes.Can you leave a prong collar on a dog all the time? ›
It is imperative the collar only be worn during walks when attached to a leash. Leaving the prong collar on a dog for extended periods can cause the prongs to embed themselves into the dog's neck which can lead to injuries and abscesses.
Do prong collars help leash reactivity? ›
Effective dog training tools are critical for leash reactivity. Your training equipment matters. It makes a difference in how you can easily and clearly communicate with your dog. We recommend using prong collars and e-collars.Should I use prong collar every walk? ›
Prong collars are meant to be put on and taken off before and after daily training sessions. Unlike a choke collar that is often left on the dog all the time (in some cases this can be a dangerous practice). A common problem new trainers have is they don't remove enough links to get the correct snug fit.Do dog trainers use prong collars? ›
A prong collar is a dog training tool used by some dog trainers to teach loose leash walking and basic beginner obedience. They can be great for behavior modification in reactive dogs to help redirect them from their triggers. Petite people with very large or strong dogs also find them incredibly helpful.How long does it take to train a dog on a prong collar? ›
It should not take more than one or two training sessions for them to fully understand how to sit properly. This command is useful in many situations.What are the pros and cons of prong collar training? ›
Pros and Cons of Prong Collars
Pros: Easy to use, inexpensive. Cons: Effectiveness depends on the dog's ability to learn from the relatively mild correction. Some dogs will still pull despite the prongs and may need a more effective solution like a static collar. They will not stop barking.
Choke and prong collars are designed to punish dogs for pulling by inflicting pain and discomfort. They can cause serious physical and emotional damage to dogs and should never be used.Do police dogs use prong collars? ›
Answer: Yes, many police dogs use prong collars while training. The police officer handling the dog will use the stationary ring of the collar when leading the dog, and sometimes the active ring when corrections might be needed.What length of time should you walk a puppy? ›
A general guide for exercising puppies is to allow them one to two sessions of five minutes walking for each month of age, so for example, a four month old pup could enjoy walks of 20 minutes at a time, once or twice a day.Why don't puppies ever want to walk on a leash? ›
When your puppy is leashed, they can't go where they want or escape from anything that frightens them. And that feeling is intimidating. Rather than seeing the leash as the predictor of an exciting walk, they see it as scary. For some puppies, even a collar can upset them.Should I leash my puppy in the backyard? ›
While walking your dog does provide them with exercise, a fenced-in backyard can, too. “The backyard is the safest option to let the dog run full tilt and burn off some steam, so both activities should be incorporated into a happy dog's lifestyle,” says Dr.
Why does my puppy bite the leash when I walk? ›
Puppies are still learning to control their most natural impulses. It makes them especially prone to biting, chewing, and tugging on their leash because it is the main thing stopping them from answering their natural urges to let loose and run free.Which is better a prong collar or a shock collar? ›
About the only thing prong collars have over shock collars is they don't have any timing component in their use. The problems with this type of collar are almost exactly the same as with shock collars above: They frequently cause new, and more serious, behavior issues to emerge such as aggression.
Use for only an hour at a time.
A prong collar is a training device and not designed for longterm use. It is not your dog's primary collar and should not be used on casual walks or outings. Use the collar for no more than one hour and only during designated training sessions.
One of the main benefits of prong collars is that they provide a more immediate and consistent correction than other types of collars, such as a flat collar or a choke chain. When a dog pulls on the leash, the prongs on the collar apply pressure to the neck and encourage them to stop pulling.Does a prong collar need to be tight? ›
A properly fit prong collar will be snug and tucked high up under the jaw line, behind the ears. This is a very sensitive area of the neck, so pressure can easily be felt. The collar can then not slide around. It should NOT be loose, low on the neck, near the shoulder or be able to easily slip over the dog's head.What size prong collar is best? ›
I normally recommend two sizes of prong collars (2.0mm small) and (3.0mm medium) the length can be adjusted to any size by adding addition links to the collar. (2.0mm) Is used as a stronger correction in any size dog. (3.0mm) is used as a mild correction in any size dog.How do I get my dog to walk nice on a leash? ›
- Fill your pocket or treat pouch with treats.
- Decide what side you'd like the dog to walk on, and hold a few treats on that side of your body. ...
- Hold your leash in the hand opposite the dog. ...
- Take a step, then stop. ...
Double-check that the collar is properly fitted. The collar should fit snugly around the dog's neck. You want to be able to fit one to two fingers between a prong on the collar and your dog's neck. The prongs should not be pressing into your dog's skin or causing any kind of pain when the leash is loose.How should you place a prong collar on a dog wag? ›
To avoid injuring your pet, make sure that the prong collar is correctly placed. It should be worn upon its neck behind its ears, with all excess links omitted so it fits tightly around the dog's neck and does not droop.At what age can you use a prong collar on a puppy? ›
Should I Use a Prong Collar on Puppies? If you have a 3- to 4-month-old puppy that is pulling you down the street while on a walk, then you need a prong collar. In this case, you won't need to 'pop' the collar to correct your puppy. The puppy will give itself a correction when he hits the end of the leash.
Does AKC recommend prong collars? ›
Special training devices that are used to control and train dogs, including but not limited to, collars with prongs, electronic collars used with transmitters, muzzles and head collars may not be used on dogs at AKC events, except as allowed in the AKC Rules, Regulations, and policies.Is it better to walk a dog on a collar or harness? ›
Harnesses bring fewer health risks
In general, harnesses are easier on dogs than collars. For example, a good harness can alleviate back pain. They're also far less likely to pull on your dog's throat, causing injury. If you have a dog that loves to pull hard while walking, you'll want to consider a harness.
We like the Herm SPRENGER Ultra-Plus Prong Dog Training Collar if this is the type of collar you'll be using. This collar has multiple size options, and many professional trainers recommend it.What age can a puppy use a prong? ›
It is not recommended to put prong collars on very young pups, usually below 3 months. The consensus is that it is safe to use prong collars at four months and upwards. Many trainers choose the ages 4-6 months as the perfect age window to start using prong collars.What age can you put collars on puppies? ›
Although it will be a few weeks before you can walk your puppy outside on a lead (prior to vaccination, you should carry your puppy to avoid the risk of infection), you can get them used to a collar once they've had a few days to settle into their new home.How do you puppy proof plugs? ›
How Do I Puppy Proof Electrical Cords? Depending on your pup, simply tucking and hiding cords behind or under furniture will work just fine. Attach cords with zip-ties to the legs of tables or desks. Another option is to run cables under rugs or along with door frames and attach them with clips to keep them in place.Can a prong collars make dogs aggressive? ›
Prong collars can result in side effects such as depression, disempowerment, redirected aggression, deterioration of social relationships, and more. Use pain and fear-inducing methods on your dog for long enough, and you can see a significant decrease in your dog's quality of life, energy, and health.How old should a puppy be to walk on a leash? ›
When Should You Start Training Your Puppy To Walk On A Leash? Puppies can learn simple commands from eight weeks old, including leash training. As soon as you've brought your puppy home and begun training, it's safe to introduce a leash/harness.Should you leave a puppies collar on all the time? ›
All veterinarians and dog trainers would agree that the collar is not designed to be a 24/7 accessory. Another good reason to remove it at night is nonstop wear could cause fur to break off leading to irritation or infection. The risk jumps if the collar frequently gets wet or if it's a bit too tight.Is a collar or harness better for a puppy? ›
In general, it's better to start your puppy's leash training with a harness and move on to a collar later. This is because puppies tend to pull strongly when first learning to walk on a leash. A collar might push on your puppy's trachea when they pull, possibly damaging it.
How do I choose a prong collar? ›
The links should be snug but not tight, and you should be able to fit one finger comfortably between a prong and your dog's skin. The collar should fit closely enough so that it does not drop down or roll around on the dog's neck, yet should not press too firmly into the dog's skin when used on a loose leash.How do I choose a prong collar for my dog? ›
Prong collars are measured by the gauge or thickness of their links. The gauge determines the actual size of the prong links and you will want to choose one appropriate for your dog. The length of the collar is much less important because links can be added or removed.How do you show a puppy where to pee? ›
Take your puppy outside frequently—at least every two hours—and immediately after they wake up, during and after playing, and after eating or drinking. Pick a bathroom spot outside, and always take your puppy (on a leash) to that spot.Does Rice plug up a dog? ›
Rice can help firm up your dog's stool because it has less fiber than other grains and binds water in the bowel instead of drawing it out like oatmeal or whole-grain cereals. But how much rice to feed a dog with diarrhea?How do I get my puppy to release something? ›
- Step 1 – Show your dog that the word “drop” earns them a food reward. First, say the word “drop” once and put a small amount of your dog's food on the floor. ...
- Step 2 – Encourage your dog to swap a toy for food. ...
- Step 3 – Wait for your dog to drop the toy before rewarding them with food.